Underdogs Tattoo Gallery

2101 Bundy Ave, New Castle, IN 47362, United States
Appearance
Underdogs Tattoo Gallery
Comments
Sy
Review №1

This place was really awesome. They recently renovated the place so it looks awesome! The place is super clean and the people are super friendly. They even have two mascots! It was such a good experience. Josh was super nice and made me feel super comfortable through-out my piercings. He got me some water after I was feeling a little queasy. He also gave great advice on the aftercare of my piercings and I plan to see him in a few months to switch things out! If you need piercings, I highly recommended this place. The tattooing looks incredible too. Thank you Underdogs!

Cr
Review №2

A big thank you to josh, he did two piercings on my daughter today, he was quick, respectful, clean and friendly. He made sure to give us his card and let us know we could reach out to him anytime, should we have questions or should an issue arise with the healing process of the piercings. The lady that works at the desk was sweet and welcoming. All staff was friendly. The overall atmosphere there made my daughter feel comfortable and I very much appreciated that. Awesome people!

Am
Review №3

We took our 5 year old daughter here to get her ears pierced. Josh is an AMAZING piercer. Very patient, polite, and informative. Took his time making sure everything was lined up and explained the procedure and aftercare very well. We even came back a week later just so he could check her ears as she was still having a lot of pain. He was leaving as we got there and took the time to go back in and see us. He said for us to email him and let him know if we have any more questions, if not he still wants us to email him so he knows she made a full recovery ok. You can tell he’s someone who loves his job and is very caring. 100/10 would recommend to anybody! The shop was also very well cleaned and maintained.

Fr
Review №4

Josh Burns was amazing to work with. We did a nose piercing and he was polite and very informative throughout the entire process. I highly recommend him to anyone looking to get a piercing done and we definitely be coming back for future work. Thank You Josh!!!!

St
Review №5

Josh was great! Got my septum pierced. He was super informative, and answered any questions I had. Will definitely go back ☺️

Ma
Review №6

Updating my review to add that this shop is always incredibly friendly and they do amazing work. They are a great tattoo shop and I recommend them every chance I get.

Jo
Review №7

What a thing it is. Thank you so much Mitch theres just nothing else to say. Thank you forever for this super unique and special thing. That was a 3 day journey Ill remember forever.Go to Underdogs. Theres nothing they cant do. Literally.

We
Review №8

I took my daughter to get her eyebrows pierced for her bday. The staff are all so nice and welcoming. Joshua Burns is an excellent piercer and explains the process thoroughly. I highly recommend this facility!

Au
Review №9

I absolutely loved my experience! Everyone was extremely cool talkative great atmosphere. I never once felt uncomfortable which is easy for me to do because of anxiety, but it was super nice! My tattoo is everything I wanted plus more. I gave Mitch two designs and he designed something totally different but the same if that makes sense! I’m just in love with it. Really liked the care package at the end as well I thought that was pretty awesome! I will definitely be getting more tattoos with underdogs!

Ro
Review №10

I took my daughter here on 1/27 to get her Daith piercing done and we had a great experience. Josh explained everything to us. Everyone was so friendly. We will definitely be back for more piercings and even some tattoos.

Dn
Review №11

I’ve been here twice, both times to have my nostril pierced. My first was probably in 2019 and my second was December of 2023. When I went in December I asked for my other nostril to be pierced and then I asked if they could switch my nose ring out for a seamless clicker hoop bc the one I had was the kind of ring that you bend apart then bend back together once it’s in. The problem with that style of hoop is they aren’t seamless. Theres always a gap that is irritating and painful when it slides through the piercing. I explained this to the piercer and said it wouldn’t be an issue and those hoops are no good for the exact reason I stated. So he pierced my nose (amazing I will add, very little pain and it’s in a great spot) but then went to change out my jewelry. I never saw the hoop before he put it in bc I didn’t think there was any misunderstanding. He takes my old hoop out then begins trying to get the new hoop in. He’s having a lot of issues though and said my nose must have had a smaller gauge that the hoop he was using so he started trying to use a taper. After about 5 minutes of this it started to become very painful. My boyfriend who came with me was sitting out by the front desk and could hear that I was in pain. He’s still trying to force this ring in and at this point it feels like he’s just re piercing my nose with a dull hoop. He gets it through eventually and then is having trouble “getting it to click together”. At this point it feels like he’s just pulling as hard as he could on my piercing trying to force the piercing closed. My nearly 4 year old piercing was bleeding and felt brand new. It felt worse that my fresh piercing. A month goes by and I notice that the ring doesn’t feel seemless now that it’s able to slide around. I look in the mirror and find out THE RING HE FORCED INTO MY NOSE ISNT A SEEMLESS CLICKER. ITS A REGULAR HOOP HE BENT APART. all that trouble, pain and extra money just for him to put in the same style of hoop we just discussed was no good bc it always had a gap that irritated the piercing when it slides through and that’s what he gave me? I am still beyond mad bc my nose still isn’t fully healed from GETTING MY JEWELRY CHANGED BY A “PROFESSIONAL” so I still can’t even change it to actual clicker seamless hoops. I’ve changed my own jewelry before and never had any trouble. I trusted that the “professional” knew what they were doing enough to change my jewelry. Then he had the gall at the end to tell me I could come back in a month and he’d changed the bar in my fresh piercing to a smaller one and I thought “yeah right, like hell I will”. I won’t be back and I won’t recommend it either.

Sa
Review №12

Just got my daughters ears pierced there for her birthday. Josh did a great job. He was super nice and professional, and clean. He changed his gloves often. I was impressed. The facility is clean and welcoming. I am super impressed with underdogs and would highly recommend them. They are great.

De
Review №13

My husband and I have both gone to Mitch for tattoo work! His skills are superb and the atmosphere is relaxing. The artists work well together, are very neat and clean, as is the parlor. And the prices...UNBEATABLE!!!! I recommend Underdogs to everyone who wants a tattoo! Attached is my most recent tattoo, from 7/19/2017, just after Mitch had finished. I have also included the reference photo I had for the tattoo. I wanted it to look like it had been done with either a paint brush or a calligraphy pen (I gave Mitch artistic freedom for that option) and it really does look like a calligraphy pen drew it!

Sh
Review №14

I got a piercing from Josh today. He was super professional and did well with my teenager as well. She’s planning on getting a nose piercing later this week. All the staff were amazing and the entire vibe of the shop was top notch! Highly recommend.

Me
Review №15

Ive gotten several tattoos from here. All the guys are very personable and make you feel comfortable. I still continue to go to them for upcoming tattoos. Chad did the vampire one and Mitch did the tarot card one. They do an amazing job.

Ki
Review №16

I reached out to get information about a tattoo for my husband as a surprise, and they were great. They got me in contact with the artist that fit my husbands style and everything!

Br
Review №17

Absolutely amazing place! Got my first tattoo yesterday at underdogs and I have to say that Mitch and Dakota made the process extremely enjoyable. Just like any first timer I was nervous but Dakota did an outstanding job of talking me through the process and making sure I was fine throughout. I am extremely pleased (actually LOVE) with the outcome and would definitely recommend this shop to everyone!!!

Az
Review №18

Dakota rocks when it comes to getting me new ink. The atmosphere is amazing and laid back. Has a slight gothic feel to it which makes me feel at home. Everyone Ive met and encountered here is truly amazing and i will always use them when I decide it is time for new ink! Thanks Underdogs!

CJ
Review №19

Dakota was very friendly along with everyone else in the shop. He was very careful with the needle and lines are so clean! Highly recommend. Will be back!

Sa
Review №20

It’s been 3 days since I got my tattoo from Chad, and I’m so in love with it! I get compliments on it at work all the time. The shading is lovely, the line work is phenomenal and the rates for how great these artists are, is very affordable! Thanks for the amazing tattoo! Can’t wait for the next.

Ky
Review №21

Josh has been my piercer for years! He’s always professional, clean, cautious, and precise. He’s pierced my ears and nose numerous times. And he’s always worth the wait! (There’s no such thing as a piercing emergency, i.e. needing something pierced at your demand.)

El
Review №22

I recently got my belly button pierced here while my mother was getting a tattoo and it was a very good experience (minus the pain lol) everyone was very friendly and professional. The shop was also very clean and well kept. I definitely enjoyed my experience in this shop and would recommend it to anyone who wants a high quality tattoo or piercing. 👍❤

Ra
Review №23

Super nice and funny people there! Went in to get a portrait of my dog who had recently passed and Mitch did such a great job! Referred several people to the shop and have already made plans to come back for more work. :)

J
Review №24

I have a new brother...his name is Zach...and he gave me a tattoo that Im proud to show all. Seriously amazing work and I cant stop staring at it! You can feel his love for tattooing and his skills were on full display. Youre a great artist my friend and my wife and I proud to wear your ink.

Em
Review №25

Great tattoos by both Mitch and Chad. Dakota has a steady hand and a good eye for piercings. I always recommend Underdogs to everyone looking for tattos and piercings. Theyre clean, considerate, have a great atmosphere, and make sure you get the best fit for you. Absolutely love them

Ka
Review №26

Mitch did a great job on my tattoo, and their new piercer, Josh Burns, has been my piercer for 4+ years. Always wonderful work and friendly atmosphere with these gentlemen!

Am
Review №27

Incredibly great people. Supported a friend reciving a tattoo from Chad. Everyone was very friendly, the establishment was clean, and the end result of my friends tattoo was phenomenal!!!If they werent so far from my current location I would reccomend them to many friends and family!

Sa
Review №28

I didnt actually get my tattoo today as I was hoping because I am pregnant, but I totally respect my artists decision. Zach saw how upset I was, as this was supposed to help me memorialize my daughter who was stillborn in February, and he offered me the gift of a charcoal drawing. I am so touched by his amazing offer, I cant thank him enough. After my child is born, I will definitely be back to get that tattoo I so desperately desire.

Br
Review №29

They did great work and are fun to spend time with. I was able to communicate with them to what I wanted, and Mitch was able to turn that into reality.

Al
Review №30

Very professional establishment. My piercing took the matter of minutes. I was informed of all the aftercare for my piercing. Would highly recommend.

Sh
Review №31

Dakota the owner gave me my Daith piercing. It hurt but Dakota was an absolute nice guy and talked to me. He wanted to make sure I was completely ok before getting up and driving home. Everyone working in their was super nice. Tiffany that works in there was the one who referred me to Dakota.

Al
Review №32

Great place mitch does wonderful color tattoos and they all are kind respectful individuals! Check out their work and go here you wont regret it! Remeber its permanent so dont go elsewhere and risk a bad tattoo! I have had a couple from here now and plan to get more when i decide what else i want down the line. At least go checn the place out or their work. Also very clean shop that has plenty of crazy interesting stuff to look at while you get your tattoo done! Im guessing they are all booked for a bit so make sure to call in advance and check!

Ho
Review №33

These guys operate a clean facility, do a great job and back up their work. They are also a lot of fun to talk to, and are really friendly! Reasonable prices for nice work, good lines and not heavy handed a bonus!

Ti
Review №34

10/10 all around. Very happy we went with these guys. 8 hours flew bye. The crew was awesome to be around and the atmosphere is great. Perfect place for anyone getting a first tattoo

Mi
Review №35

Chad brought to life the vision I had for my memorial piece. I love it. My Grandmother loved.

Ma
Review №36

My piercer was extremely professional. Walked me through the process. I was in good hands there. The rest of the staff was super friendly too

Da
Review №37

I only go to Chad for all of my work. Him and Mitch both have became (in my opinion) the best tattoo artists around in such short time. Their work speaks for itself.

Ca
Review №38

Zach was my artist. If you are looking to get a new tattoo, it is worth the wait to go to these guys. They are all ridiculously talented. 10 stars.

Am
Review №39

Amazing artist who always try their best to work with you to get exactly what you want. And their piercer is patient, always explains everything he is about to do before he does it to help you stay comfortable.

Yv
Review №40

Will not go anywhere else for ink. Zach did my tat, very friendly, laid back, and quite hilarious. Made for a overall good experience. Highly recommend this shop.

De
Review №41

I did not visit but, my wife and daughter went in to get their ears pierced. Very clean and awesome atmosphere.

Ho
Review №42

I had my first tattoo here by Macey a few weeks ago. It was a great experience, and I love my tattoo.

Ta
Review №43

The shop is clean and everyone is very friendly. Chad is an amazing artist. Will always recommend him and the rest of the crew. A+++ service

Sa
Review №44

The tattoos Ive seen done there are absolutely stunning. And its the best place for piercings Ive ever been to. I wont go anywhere else!!

Ti
Review №45

Daughter got her nose pierced. Very professional and clean. Will go back again for sure.

Br
Review №46

Chad did amazing. Ill definitely be going back. I gave him a picture that I was told elsewhere wasnt possible to do and he did it perfectly.

Je
Review №47

A amazing place very friendly laid back and cool enjoy going there the art work is amazing the piercer is great! They all are inviting !!!! Love there work

Pa
Review №48

Super Happy!! Loved my experience! Love my new tattoos! 10/10 recommend!! 😊💜

Ph
Review №49

They do amazing job mitch and Zack are the best..Best place around to get any kind of tattoo work.

Ru
Review №50

Mitch was very friendly and did a great job on my sons tattoo. Thanks!!

Mi
Review №51

Josh is the best #1 piercer! Very knowledgeable and easy going. !!!

Jo
Review №52

Real nice people! Dakota did a fine job on my tattoos.

Me
Review №53

Chad did my tattoo and im very happy with the work. Great atmosphere also.

An
Review №54

Talented artists that put a lot of thought and effort into your own personal piece of art. Highly recommend!

ER
Review №55

Really nice work, they even do body piercing. A little high in price, but you get what you pay for

Br
Review №56

Very friendly place and staff!

Ja
Review №57

I tried contacting them for 2 simple tattoos and couldn’t get an appointment.

bu
Review №58

Comfortable, cool , good artists, piercer is also very cool

Re
Review №59

LOVE❤️, my new ink today! Thank You Mitch

An
Review №60

Love it! Super friendly staff and very clean. Will be going back for sure.

Ma
Review №61

The guys here are great at what they do and definitely create an inviting atmosphere.

Ke
Review №62

Zachs work is second to none!! Great experience highly recommend!!!!

Jo
Review №63

Mitch, you are the man for tattoos to me. Thank you for an awesome job...

St
Review №64

Great price, amazing employees 30 out of 10 recommend

De
Review №65

Great time there, helluva group of people and some great and hilarious conversations!

Sa
Review №66

Had both piercings and tats done here and they rock

Do
Review №67

Chad does good work

Le
Review №68

Thank you so much! We appreciate everything.

La
Review №69

Beautiful and painless! Just what I wanted 😃 Ask for Mitch❗

Ha
Review №70

Gotta love when a hottie gives ya the needle. 10/10

La
Review №71

Always top notch quality and the staff treat you as equal.

Dr
Review №72

Great studio. Great crew. Check them out.

St
Review №73

Nice place

ma
Review №74

Home to some of the best artists in the state!

Ty
Review №75

Have never been dissatisfied or disappointed by the work in the shop!

Le
Review №76

Super cool people and pretty dope artists

Re
Review №77

Mitch is an amazing artist!

Mi
Review №78

See Mitch. I couldnt have asked for a better experience.

Ax
Review №79

Nice people and environment, quality work.

Br
Review №80

Great shop great experience and great people

C.
Review №81

Great artists and staff.

Mr
Review №82

Great guys great tattoos

Br
Review №83

Loved it!

Ma
Review №84

Nice

Na
Review №85

Excellent people!💯

Vi
Review №86

Amazing shop!!

Information
77 Photos
86 Comments
4.9 Rating
  • Address:2101 Bundy Ave, New Castle, IN 47362, United States
  • Site:http://underdogstattoogallery.com/
  • Phone:+1 765-686-9097
Categories
  • Tattoo and piercing shop
Working hours
  • Monday:Closed
  • Tuesday:12–6 PM
  • Wednesday:12–6 PM
  • Thursday:12–6 PM
  • Friday:12–6 PM
  • Saturday:12–6 PM
  • Sunday:Closed
Accessibility
  • Wheelchair-accessible car park:Yes
  • Wheelchair-accessible entrance:Yes
  • Wheelchair-accessible seating:Yes
  • Wheelchair-accessible toilet:Yes
Amenities
  • Gender-neutral toilets:Yes
Crowd
  • LGBTQ+ friendly:Yes
  • Transgender safe space:Yes
Payments
  • Debit cards:Yes
  • NFC mobile payments:Yes
  • Credit cards:Yes
Similar organizations